Podcast – What Are the Key Differences Between Hot Runners and Cold Runners in Injection Molding?

A comparison between hot and cold runners in injection molding
What Are the Key Differences Between Hot Runners and Cold Runners in Injection Molding?
Nov 09 - MoldAll - Explore expert tutorials, case studies, and guides on mold design and injection molding. Learn hands-on skills to enhance your craft at MoldAll.

All right, let's dive into injection molding.
Yeah.
Specifically, hot runners versus cold runners.
Okay.
And whether you're, like, an engineer or just curious about how everyday stuff gets made.
Right.
This choice, like, it really impacts everything it does. The quality, cost, even the design of things you use every day.
Absolutely.
Think about that phone case you're holding, or maybe you built Legos as a kid. All of that stuff. Injection molding. And these runners played a part.
Yeah.
We've got excerpts from a technical article today breaking it all down.
Okay, cool.
So get ready for some, like, insider knowledge.
That's right.
Without all the jargon.
And while injection molding might seem pretty simple, just injecting molten plastic into a mold.
Right.
The choice between hot and cold runners is a big deal for manufacturers.
Okay, so before we get too far.
Yeah.
What exactly are these runners?
So imagine you're trying to get that molten plastic to flow into, like, the really thin space of a phone case mold or something.
Okay.
It needs a path, a carefully designed pathway.
Right.
And that's where the runners come in.
Okay.
There are channels that guide that molten plastic from, like, the injection point into the mold cavities, sort of like a branching river system delivering that liquid plastic to where it needs to go.
So they're like the veins and arteries of the injection molding process.
Exactly.
Okay, I got it.
Yeah.
But why are we so concerned about the difference between hot and cold?
Well, because it has huge implications. Okay, think about it like this.
Okay?
A cold runner. The plastic solidifies inside the runner after each injection cycle.
Okay.
It's like you have a traffic jam that you have to clear before more cars can get through.
So that sounds inefficient.
Yeah.
What about the hot runners?
Hot runners are like the express lane. They keep the plastic molten the entire time. The entire time, using these heating elements. Like. Precisely.
So, like, it's faster.
Way faster.
Okay. Like, how much faster?
Well, the article we're looking at mentions time savings of over 20% with hot runners.
Wow.
So imagine, you know, shaving off a fifth of your production time.
That's incredible.
You can get a lot more done.
Yeah.
More products, faster turnaround, quicker response to market demands.
So not only is it faster, but I imagine it's also way more efficient, energy wise. Right.
Exactly.
Less time heating and cooling, less energy wasted overall.
And here's where it gets even better.
Okay.
Less waste overall because the plastic never solidifies in the runner.
Right.
There's nothing to discard after each cycle. Oh, so you're using less material.
That's Good for the environment.
It is.
And also your wallet.
Win win.
A triple win for manufacturers and the planet.
So wait, the plastic stays liquid the whole time?
Yeah.
But doesn't it need to cool to harden?
It does.
Okay.
But that's. That cooling process is very, very controlled.
And hot runners can maintain precise temperatures so the plastic flows uniformly, leading to fewer defects.
Okay.
Imagine you've got two streams of plastic meeting imperfectly.
Yeah.
That's a weld line. And it can create a weak spot.
Oh, right.
Hot runners, they minimize those, giving you a much stronger and more visually appealing product.
So like a smoother finish with no weak points.
Yeah.
Okay. Got it.
That's important for things that need to be durable.
Absolutely. But what about cost?
Yeah.
All this fancy tech, it's got to be expensive. Right?
There is a higher upfront cost.
Right.
No doubt about it.
Okay.
You're paying for those sophisticated heating elements.
Yeah.
Those precise controls. It's like the luxury model with all the bells and whistles.
Okay.
But there's another factor to consider.
Okay, lay it on me.
What if you're a small startup.
Okay.
Just starting out.
Right.
And you need to create prototypes.
Yeah.
And you're on a budget.
Right.
Or maybe you're a small business.
Yeah.
Producing simple items in small batches.
Yeah.
This is where cold runners can actually make a lot of sense.
Okay. Because they're the budget friendly option.
Exactly.
Like choosing the reliable, no frills workhorse instead of the flashy sports car.
You got it. They're simpler in design, less expensive to set up initially.
Makes sense.
But like most things in life, there are trade offs.
Okay. So let's unpack those trade offs. What are we sacrificing by going the budget route with the cold runner?
Well, remember that traffic jam analogy?
Yes.
With cold runners, after each cycle, that solidified plastic has to be ejected.
Okay.
And a lot of times reground for potential recycling.
Got it.
And this adds time to the cycle, of course. Increases energy usage.
Right.
And even though you can reuse some of that material, it's just not as efficient.
So it's like taking the scenic route. You might save a little up front, but you end up spending more time and resources getting there.
Precisely.
Yeah.
And that's not all.
What else?
Remember how those hot runners maintain that perfect temperature?
Yeah.
Ensures a smooth, uniform flow.
Right.
Well, cold runners can lead to uneven cooling.
Okay.
The plastic in the center of that solidified runner cools slower than the edges.
Got it.
And that creates internal stresses which can actually warp the final product.
So you might End up with a phone case that doesn't quite fit.
Yeah.
Or a toy with a weird bend.
Right.
Not ideal.
Not at all.
Okay, so we've got slower cycle times, increased waste, and the potential for, like, wonky products.
Right.
Are there any situations where cold runners are actually the better option?
Absolutely.
Okay, good.
There are times when they are the perfect choice.
Like when?
Let's say you're a company that makes large, simple parts.
Okay.
Like those big plastic planters you see at garden centers.
Yeah.
The design is basic.
Right.
The tolerances are more forgiving.
Yeah.
Warping isn't a major concern.
So in that case, the simplicity and the lower cost of a cold runner make it a great fit.
Exactly.
It's all about choosing the right tool for the job.
Exactly.
Awesome.
And there's another interesting scenario where cold runners often win out.
What's that?
Some plastics, especially those with, like, funky additives in them.
Oh, okay.
Are really sensitive to the constant heat of a hot runner system.
Oh, interesting.
They might degrade or change properties over time with that constant heat.
Oh, wow.
So.
So it's kind of like choosing the right cooking method for different ingredients.
That's a good way to put it.
Some things thrive under high heat.
Yeah.
Others need a gentler approach.
Exactly.
Okay, now I'm thinking that all sorts of things we use every day, like water bottles or even car parts.
Yeah.
How do manufacturers decide which runner system to use?
Well, it all boils down to asking the right questions.
Okay.
First off, how many units are you making?
Okay.
High volume production, like those millions of water bottles that screams hot runners. The speed and efficiency gains are just essential.
But for smaller batches.
Yeah.
Cold runners might be perfectly adequate.
Could be.
Okay, so production volume is key.
It is.
What else should they consider?
Think about the product itself.
Okay.
Are you making, like, a high precision part that fits into a complex machine, or is it a simple single piece item?
Right.
So intricate designs.
Yeah.
With tight tolerances often need the precision of hot runners.
Makes sense.
While simpler items can handle the slight variations that might come with cold runners.
Got it.
Yeah.
And of course, we can't forget about the plastic itself.
Right.
Some materials, like those high melting point plastics.
Yeah.
They're a perfect match for hot runners. They are. Flow beautifully at those higher temperatures.
Like a perfectly smooth chocolate fountain.
Ooh, that's a good analogy.
It highlights that material compatibility is absolutely crucial.
Yeah.
The wrong combination can lead to all sorts of headaches.
Right. Like what?
Like inconsistent flow, degraded materials.
Oh, no. So it's really a balancing act.
It is.
You've got to consider the production volume, the product's complexity, the material, the budget.
Of course.
And of course the budget.
Always the budget.
It's fascinating how a choice that seems so technical can actually impact so many aspects of the manufacturing process.
It really is.
From cost to environmental impact to the quality of the final product.
Yeah. It shows you that there's more to everyday objects than meets the eye.
Right.
There's a whole world of engineering and decision making behind that seemingly simple water bottle.
It makes you appreciate the things we use every day on a whole new level.
It does.
I'm looking at my phone case right now. I'm like hot runner or cold runner.
I know, right?
What about you?
Yeah.
Has this changed the way you think about the things you use?
It definitely has. For me.
Yeah.
It's like I've unlocked a secret code and now I can't help but see those subtle clues of the manufacturing process everywhere I look.
It's like becoming a detective of the everyday.
Exactly.
Okay. I'm ready to wrap this up with a final thought here.
Okay.
We've talked a lot about the practicalities, hot versus cold runners, the cost, the efficiency, the quality. But let's take a step back.
Okay.
And think bigger picture for a second.
I like where you're going with this.
Okay.
What are you thinking?
Well, we touched on environmental impact, but I think it deserves a little more attention.
Okay. I agree.
Remember how hot runners completely eliminate that solidified plastic waste?
Yeah.
That's huge.
Huge for sustainability.
Yeah.
Less plastic going to landfills.
Right.
Less need for those energy intensive recycling processes.
Yeah.
It's like choosing the eco friendly option with every single part.
With every single part you make. Exactly.
Yeah.
It really highlights how these seemingly small decisions in manufacturing.
Right.
Can have this huge ripple effect on the environment.
They do.
It's about making conscious choices that benefit both the bottom line and the planet.
Absolutely.
And that's a message that's resonating more and more these days.
It is.
Consumers are becoming more savvy about sustainability and they're looking for products that are made with those practices in mind. So choosing hot runners can actually be a win win. You're making a better product and you're appealing to a growing segment of eco consumers.
Exactly.
It's a smart business move.
It is.
And a step towards a more sustainable future.
Absolutely.
And it all comes back to being informed.
Yeah.
Understanding those hidden connections between the choices we make and the impact that they have.
Right.
And that's what we're all about here on the deep dive.
That's Right.
Empowering you with the knowledge to make those informed choices.
Right.
Whether you are a manufacturer deciding on a runner system or a consumer just choosing between products.
Exactly.
So next time you're holding something, a seemingly simple object.
Yeah.
Take a moment to consider its journey.
Right.
Think about the materials, the design, the process, the manufacturing process, even the runners that went into making it a reality.
It's like unlocking a hidden world. Seeing those everyday objects with new eyes.
You might start to notice the signs of a weld line or the feel of a perfectly smooth surface. The hints of the choices that were made along. Along the way.
It's about appreciating the ingenuity, the innovation, and the impact of those choices.
Absolutely.
On our world.
Who knows? Maybe this has sparked some curiosity in you.
I hope so.
Maybe you're inspired to learn more about the world of manufacturing.
That'd be awesome.
To explore the how and the why behind the things we use every day.
Because knowledge is power.
It is.
The more we understand about how things are made.
Yeah.
The better equipped we are to shape a more sustainable and innovative future. Thank you.
And on that note, we've reached the end of our deep dive into hot and cold runners.
It's been fun.
I hope you enjoyed the journey.
I did.
And you're walking away with a new appreciation for this intricate world of manufacturing.
Me too.
It's been a pleasure exploring this with you.
Likewise.
Thanks for joining us.
Of course.
Until next time. Keep asking questions.
Keep learning.
Keep learning.
Keep diving deep. Keep diving deep into the world around you.
Into the world around you.
Absolutely.
See you next time.
Remember that traffic jam we talked about?
Oh, yeah. With the cold runners.
Yeah. So after every cycle, that plastic, you know, inside the runner solidifies.
Right.
And it has to get ejected.
Okay.
A lot of times they'll regrind it.
Oh.
To potentially recycle it.
Got it.
And this adds a bunch of time to the cycle.
Yeah.
Uses more energy.
Right.
And even though you can, you know, reuse some of that material.
Right.
It's just not as efficient.
It's not as efficient as just keeping it liquid the whole time.
Right.
Okay.
And that's not all.
Oh, no. There's more.
So remember how hot runners maintain that perfect temperature?
Yeah.
Everything flows smoothly. Well, cold runners can lead to uneven cooling.
Okay.
The plastic in the center of that solidified runner.
Right.
It cools slower than the stuff at the edges.
Oh, okay.
And this can create internal stresses that warp the final product.
So, like, you end up with a phone case that doesn't quite Fit, Right.
Exactly.
Or like a toy with a weird bend. Not ideal.
Not ideal.
So slower cycle times, increased waste.
Yeah.
Potentially messed up products.
Right.
Are there any situations where like cold runners are actually the better option?
Absolutely.
Okay.
Yeah, there are times where they're the perfect choice.
Okay, give me an example.
Let's say you're a company making like large, simple parts like those big plastic planters. You see a garden center. Yeah.
Okay.
Yeah. The design is basic.
Right.
Tolerances are, you know, more forgiving. Yeah. Warping isn't a big deal.
Okay.
So in that case, a cold runner makes a lot of sense.
Right. You get the simplicity, the lower cost.
Exactly.
It's all about using the right tool for the job.
It is, it is.
And I bet there are even more situations where cold runners make more sense.
You know what, you're right. Oh, there's another interesting scenario where cold runners, they often win out.
Lay it on me.
So some plastics, especially those with, you know, funky additives.
Okay.
Those can be really sensitive to the constant heat.
Ah. From the hot runner.
Yeah. Of a hot runner system.
Got it.
They might degrade or change properties.
All that heat.
Yeah. Over time, with that constant heat.
So you have to pick the right plastic.
You do.
So it's like choosing the right cooking method for different ingredients.
That's a really good way to put it.
Some things like high heat, other things need to be treated a little gentler. Now I'm thinking about all the stuff we use every day.
Yeah.
Water bottles.
Right.
Car parts. How do manufacturers know which runner sister to use?
It's all about asking the right questions.
Alright, so what's the first question they should ask?
Well, first off, how many of these things are you making?
Okay. Yeah, that makes sense.
If it's high volume production.
Like millions of water bottles.
Yeah. Like millions of water bottles. Hot runners are the way to go.
Makes sense.
The speed and efficiency are just too important.
But for smaller batches.
Yeah.
For smaller batches, cold runners are probably fine.
They could be.
So production volume is key.
It's a big one.
Okay. What else?
Think about the product itself.
Right.
Are you making like a high precision part?
Yeah.
That fits into like a complex machine?
Okay.
Or is it something simple, just a single piece?
Okay.
Intricate designs, tight tolerances.
Yeah.
Those often need hot runners.
Right. Because they're more precise. While simpler things, you know, you can get away with cold runners.
Right. They can handle those slight variations. And then of course, don't forget about the plastic itself.
Oh, right.
From materials like the high melting point plastics. Those are a Perfect match for hot runners.
Yeah. Because they flow well at those high temperatures.
They do.
Like a chocolate fountain.
Like a chocolate fountain. Exactly.
It's a good one.
It really highlights that material compatibility is so important.
It is.
I mean, the wrong combination can cause all sorts of problems.
Like what?
Inconsistent flow.
Right.
Degraded materials.
Oh, man.
It can be a mess.
So it really is a balancing act.
It is.
You have to consider the volume, the complexity, the material, and of course, always the budget.
The budget.
It's amazing how something that seems so technical.
I know, right?
Impacts so many different parts of the process.
Yeah. It really is.
The cost, the environmental impact, the quality.
It just shows you there's so much more to these everyday objects than you think.
Right.
There's a whole world of engineering and decision making behind that simple water bottle.
It really makes you appreciate the things we use every day in a whole new way.
It really does.
I'm looking at my phone case now, and I'm like, hmm.
I know, right?
Hot runner. Cold runner.
Exactly.
What about you?
Yeah.
Has this deep dive changed the way you think about the things you use?
It really has.
How so?
It's like I've unlocked a secret code.
Right.
And I see these clues about manufacturing everywhere.
Everywhere you look, everywhere. You're like a detective of the everyday.
Exactly.
Okay, so before we wrap up.
Yeah.
I want to talk about one last thing.
Okay.
We talked about the environmental impact.
We did.
But I think we need to give it a little more attention.
Okay, I'm with you.
So remember how we were talking about how hot runners can totally get rid of that solid plastic waste?
Yeah. It's a big deal.
That's a big win for sustainability.
For sure.
Less plastic in landfills. Less need to use all that energy to recycle stuff.
Right, right.
It's like you're choosing the environmentally friendly option with every single part.
Yeah. With every single part.
These small choices in manufacturing can have a big impact on the planet. It's about making those choices that are good for business.
Absolutely.
But also good for the environment.
Both. You got it. Both.
And people are starting to really care about that.
Oh, yeah, for sure.
Consumers are getting smarter, more aware about sustainability.
Yeah.
And they want things that are made responsibly.
Absolutely.
So using hot runners can be a win. Win is make a better product, attract those customers who care about the planet.
It's smart.
Smart for business.
Yeah.
Good for the environment.
And it all comes down to being informed.
Right.
Understanding how these choices we make impact everything.
And that's what we try to do here.
That's right.
On the deep dive.
Yeah.
Give you the information you need, the knowledge, so you can make those choices.
Right.
Whether you're the one making the stuff or the one buying it.
Exactly.
So think about it.
Yeah.
The next time you're holding something, just a regular, everyday object, something simple, think about how it got there.
The journey.
Think about the materials, the way it's designed, how it was made, how it was made. Even the runner.
It's like seeing the world in a new way.
You might start to notice things you never saw before.
Like those weld lines.
Right.
Or how smooth the surface is.
Yeah. Those little clues about the choices they made.
It's about appreciating all the work that went into it. The ingenuity, the innovation, and how it impacts the world around us.
Maybe you're even a little curious now. Want to learn more?
I hope so.
About how stuff is made.
Yeah. That'd be awesome.
Figure out the how and the why of it all.
Because knowledge is power.
It really is.
The more we understand about how these things are made.
Yeah.
The better we can make the future.
Make it more sustainable, make it more innovative.
That's what we need.
That's a great point.
Thank you.
Well, that brings us to the end. To the end of the road of our deep dive.
Yeah.
Into the world of hot and cold runners.
Those little but important runners.
I hope you learned something new.
I know I did.
And you're leaving with a new appreciation for manufacturing.
Me too.
It's been awesome exploring this with you.
Likewise.
Thanks for joining us on the deep dive.
Of course.
Keep asking those questions.
Keep learning. Keep diving deep into the world around you.
See you next