Podcast – How Do Injection Pressure and Holding Pressure Differ?

A clean industrial facility with advanced machinery for raw material preparation
How Do Injection Pressure and Holding Pressure Differ?
Nov 27 - MoldAll - Explore expert tutorials, case studies, and guides on mold design and injection molding. Learn hands-on skills to enhance your craft at MoldAll.

Okay. So you've sent us a whole bunch of articles about injection molding, it looks like.
Yeah.
And you're really zeroing in on injection pressure and holding pressure. But as I think you're discovering, these pressures, they're like the unsung heroes they are of really nailing those plastic parts.
They can make or break your part. Absolutely.
We're going to break it all down for you in this deep dive.
Sounds good.
See how these pressures affect quality and how to optimize them.
Right.
The cool thing is your sources have tons of stories about, you know, what.
Works, what doesn't work, people making mistakes and learning from it.
Yeah, exactly. And that's how we all learn, Right?
Exactly. Learn from your mistakes.
So to get us started, let's quickly define these two big players.
Okay.
Injection pressure is that force that pushes the plastic into the mold.
Yeah. It's like the engine.
It's like the engine. Right.
Pushing everything through.
And holding pressure is that steady force while the plastic cools.
Yeah. Make sure it stays nice and dense.
Keeps it from shrinking back.
Yeah.
Now, one of your sources has this great analogy for injection pressure. They compare it to squeezing a tube of toothpaste.
Yeah.
Get the pressure just right, and you get a nice smooth flow.
Yeah. That's it. But squeeze too hard, you make a mess.
A big mess. And injection molding, that means air bubbles, burn marks.
Yeah.
Even a messed up mold, you can.
Actually damage the mold. Yeah. It's happened to me before, really early in my career working with a new plastic. And I didn't change the injection pressure from the last project. Rookie mistake.
So what happened? A bunch of rejects.
Worse. I ruined the mold.
Wow.
Yeah. Expensive lesson.
Yeah.
But it taught me how different plastics react to different pressures.
Yeah. So it's not just about like, memorizing a chart. It's more than that.
Much more. It's about understanding how the materials and the pressure work together.
Okay, so we've got. Got the injection pressure pushing that plastic in, but what about holding pressure? Right. One of your articles called it the Silent Hero.
Yeah, I love that.
I thought that was great because it's.
Easy to forget about it, but it's so important.
Yeah. So injection pressure fills the mold, but holding pressure, it keeps the pressure there as the plastic cools.
Exactly. It keeps it from shrinking and getting those little defects, you know, like sink marks and voids.
And you had an example in your articles where neglecting holding pressure caused a big problem.
Yeah, this happens all the time. You have a beautiful part right out of the press. Right and as it cools, you start to see those sink marks on the surface. Oh.
So it's not just how it looks right away, it's about the long term strength too, right?
Absolutely. If there's not enough holding pressure.
Yeah.
The plastic doesn't pack tightly during cooling.
Right.
So you get those voids and weak spots that can make the part break. It's like building a house on a bad foundation.
So just like injection pressure, you can have too much holding pressure.
Oh, yeah, for sure.
What happens then?
Too much and you get flashing. That's when the plastic squeezes out of the mold seams. You can even warp the part, especially within walls.
So finding that right balance with holding pressure is just as important as getting the injection pressure right?
Absolutely.
It's like a dance.
It is. You need to find that sweet spot where you get a dense part without any defects.
And your articles mention this guy Jackie from Canada, who said that's like a key skill in injection molding.
Jackie's the best.
He talks about developing a feel for it.
He's right. It's not just plugging numbers into a machine. It's about understanding the material, the mold, the whole process.
So experience is super important here.
Oh, absolutely. But even with years of experience, I still go back to the basics. And that's where the next section of your articles comes. And the part about adjusting those pressures.
Okay, perfect. Let's get into that. All right, let's do it.
Sounds good. Now this is where it gets practical.
Yeah. This is what I'm interested in.
This is what you need to know.
Yeah. How to actually use this stuff.
Exactly.
One of your articles has this table. It tells you when you might need to change those injection and holding pressures.
It's like a cheat sheet for anyone doing injection molding.
Perfect.
Covers all sorts of scenarios.
Yeah. I had a question about thin walled parts. Those are always tricky. What does the table say about those?
It says high injection pressure, which makes sense because you need that extra oomph to fill those thin sections. But here's the thing. Moderate holding pressure.
Why moderate? Wouldn't you want to keep the pressure high so it doesn't shrink?
You would, but with thin walls, there's a risk of warping if the holding pressure is too high. Like if you squeeze a pastry too hard, you'll ruin it.
So another balancing act it is. What about parts with really complex designs?
Oh, those can be a headache.
Yeah. Lots of detail.
Lots of detail.
What does the table say?
Same approach as thin walled parts. High injection pressure to get all those Details, but lower holding pressure so you don't stress the mold.
Makes sense. Especially if the mold itself has all those details.
Right. You don't want to mess up those details by pushing too hard.
You mentioned before that experience is really key. Here.
It is.
So any tips for someone just starting out? How do they even figure out where to start with these settings?
Great question. The best thing I learned is don't be afraid to experiment.
Within reason, of course. Yeah.
Start with what the table says and then just make little changes, See what happens.
The trial and error, kind of.
But it's not just random.
Right.
You got to pay attention to what's happening. Look for those little signs.
Like what?
Like sink marks or short shots. Even a tiny bit of warping. All those are telling you something needs to change.
That's where that feel comes in that Jackie was talking about.
Exactly. It's recognizing the patterns, knowing how the pressure affects the plastic.
Right.
And then knowing what to do to get the results you want.
It's like being a detective.
It is. You're solving a mystery.
And one of your sources talked about using simulation software.
Oh, yeah.
That sounds like a high tech detective tool.
It is. You can test different pressure settings virtually before you even make the part.
Wow. So you don't waste material or break a mold.
Exactly. You can try all sorts of things, find potential problems, and tweak the settings all before you start production.
That's got to be valuable, especially for complex parts or when you're using a new material.
Oh, yeah. It gives you the freedom to experiment without the risk.
And he said the material you're using really matters for figuring out the right pressure.
It does. Different plastics act differently under pressure. Some shrink more. Some are sensitive to temperature changes. You got to know what you're working with.
You mentioned nylon before being tricky because it shrinks a lot.
It does.
Any other materials that are difficult to work with?
Oh, yeah, tons. Polycarbonate, for example. It doesn't shrink as much as nylon, so you don't need as much holding pressure. And then you have stuff like peak. Peak? Yeah. It melts at really high temperatures, so you need higher injection pressure just to get it to flow.
So it's not just knowing the general rules, it's knowing how they apply to the specific plastic you're using.
Exactly. And there are tons of resources out there, you know, online and in manuals, that'll tell you all about the shrinkage rates, melt temperatures, everything you need to know.
So much to learn.
There is. It never gets boring, but there's something Jackie said that really stuck with me.
What was that?
He said the best molders aren't just button pushers, they're problem solvers. I love that.
That's a good one.
It's not just about following the rules. It's about understanding why things happen and being able to figure out how to fix them.
Okay, so we've talked materials, pressures. What about the mold itself?
The mold.
That's where it all happens, right?
It is. And the design of that mold can really affect the pressure settings.
One of your articles had a case study where they messed up the mold design and it caused problems.
Oh, yeah. That company trying to make those tiny medical parts.
Yeah. Super detailed.
Super detailed. They were so focused on those details that they forgot about how the mold shape would affect the pressure.
What happened? Did they get a bunch of bad parts?
Worse. They broke the mold.
Oh, no.
Yeah. The pressure in some spots was so high, it cracked the mold. Costly repairs and delays.
Ouch. So you got to think about the mold design and the pressure settings together.
Absolutely. And that's where simulation software can be really helpful again.
Yeah.
You can see how different mold designs will affect the pressure before you even build the mold.
So it's like preventing problems before they happen.
Exactly. Now, we've talked about experimenting with pressure settings to get that perfect balance. Right, but are there any general rules to keep in mind when you're making adjustments?
Yeah. What are the best practices?
Well, one of the. The most important is to start with injection pressure. Get that right first because that's what fills the mold.
Right.
Once you've got that dialed in, then you can fine tune the holding pressure.
So two steps, injection, then holding.
Exactly. One of the articles had a little saying to help remember that? Fill, then hold.
Fill, then hold. I like it.
Simple but effective.
Easy to remember.
Another important tip is to make small changes.
Oh, okay.
Don't go changing everything all at once.
So be patient.
Be patient. Start small, see what happens, then adjust from there.
So it's more like science than just guessing.
Exactly. You're collecting data, analyzing it, and then making informed decisions.
You said earlier that even small changes in pressure can make a big difference.
Oh, yeah, they can.
What's an example?
Let's say you're seeing some sink marks. Instead of cranking up the holding pressure, which could cause other problems.
Right.
Just increase it by like 5% or 10% and see what happens. You might be surprised.
So it's about being subtle.
It is. It's like you're whispering to the plastic instead of yelling at it.
You Mentioned that holding pressure can actually affect how the part performs over time.
Right. It's all about residual stress.
Now, I remember that from the articles, but it was a bit technical.
It can be.
Can you explain it simply?
Okay, so imagine all the tiny molecules in the plastic trying to find their place as the part cools.
Okay.
If the holding pressure is not right, those molecules get stuck in a kind of tension.
So it's, like, trapped inside the part.
Exactly. And that stress can make the part warp or crack later on.
So it's not just about how it looks when it comes out of the mold. It's about how it holds up over time.
Absolutely.
You said different materials shrink differently, which affects holding pressure. Does that also affect this residual stress?
It does. Materials that shrink more tend to have more residual stress, especially if you don't use enough holding pressure to counteract that shrinkage.
So if you're using something like nylon, you really got to pay attention to that holding pressure.
You do. And there are techniques like annealing, where you heat and cool the part in a controlled way that can help relieve some of that residual stress.
Though another layer of complexity.
It is, but it's another way to fine tune the process and get the best possible results.
We talked about holding pressure and residual stress. What about injection pressure? Does that have an effect too?
It can, but in a different way. Holding pressure is all about packing and shrinkage during cooling.
Okay.
But injection pressure affects. Affects how the plastic flows into the mold. If the injection pressure is too high, it can actually push the plastic in too fast.
Okay.
And that creates sheer stresses, which can add to the residual stress later on.
So finding the right injection pressure is important too.
It is. You need enough pressure to fill the mold, but not so much that you create extra stress.
And that's where temperature comes in, right?
Ah, yes. Temperature. The secret ingredient.
Okay, tell me more about how temperature affects things.
We've been talking a lot about pressure, but temperature is just as important. It affects the viscosity of the plastic.
Viscosity? What's that?
Basically how easily the plastic flows.
Okay.
So if the temperature is too low, the plastic might be too thick, and even high injection pressure won't make it flow. Right. And if it's too hot, the plastic might flow too easily, and you could get flashing or even damage the material.
So you got to get the temperature just right, too.
You do. It's all about balance.
One of your articles said that temperature changes during molding can cause problems with the quality of the parts.
Absolutely. You need to keep the temperature consistent throughout the whole process.
So those fancy temperature control systems on modern molding machines are pretty important.
They are. They help keep everything stable and predictable.
It's amazing how much technology is helping with injection molding.
It is. But even with all the technology, you still need to understand the basics.
Right.
And you need to be able to figure things out when something goes wrong.
Now, we've talked a lot about the technical side of things.
We have.
But one of the things I love about injection molding is that human element.
You know, it's a mix of science and art, isn't it?
It is, yeah. You have all the data and calculations, but you also need intuition and experience.
Absolutely. And sometimes you need to get creative.
Speaking of creativity, one of the articles mentioned this technique called pack and hold for optimizing holding pressure.
Oh, yeah, I've used that one. It can be really effective.
How does it work?
So instead of keeping the holding pressure the same during cooling, you do it in two steps. First, you use a higher pack pressure for a short time to really force the plastic into every corner of the mold. Then you lower the pressure to a hold level to keep it packed as it cools.
So you give it an extra push at the beginning and then ease off.
Exactly. It helps to get a really dense part without any voids.
We've talked about a lot of techniques for getting the pressure settings right.
We have.
But what are some common mistakes that people make?
Oh, there are a few. One of the biggest is not purging the machine properly before starting a new run.
Urging. What's that?
Basically, cleaning out any leftover plastic from the last run.
Oh, okay.
You don't want that old plastic mixing with the new plastic.
Makes sense. So it's like cleaning your paintbrush before you start a new painting.
Exactly. You want a fresh start.
What else did people mess up?
Cooling time.
Cooling time. How does that affect the pressure?
Well, the cooling time determines how fast the plastic hardens in the mold. If you don't give it enough time, the part might warp or distort when you take it out.
So even if the pressure is perfect, if you rush the cooling, you can still mess it up.
Exactly. And it's not just about the total cooling time.
What else?
You gotta make sure the part cools evenly.
Okay.
You don't want the outside to cool super fast while the inside is still molten.
That would cause problems.
You could get warping or cracking.
So injection molding, it's not just about pressure and temperature. It's about understanding how the plastic behaves and how it Cools.
It is. It's a complex process, but that's what makes it so interesting.
I was reading about companies using sensors to measure the pressure inside the mold while it's running.
Oh, yeah. In mold. Pressure sensors.
Have you used those?
I have. It's a newer technology, but it's really helpful, especially for high precision molding. How they work, you basically put tiny sensors right inside the mold cavity.
Wow.
And they measure the pressure as the plastic fills the mold and as it cools. That data gets sent back to the machine so it can adjust the pressures automatically.
So it's like having a little spy inside the mold telling you what's going on.
It is. You get real time feedback so you can make sure everything's perfect.
Pretty cool. We've talked about a lot of advanced stuff today.
We have.
But I want to go back to that idea of feeling.
Yeah.
How does someone new to injection molding develop that intuition?
That's the million dollar question. There's no easy answer. It comes from experience, observation, and a willingness to try new things and learn from your mistakes.
So it's a journey.
It is. And the best way to start that journey is to find a mentor.
Someone's been doing this for a while.
Exactly. Someone who can show you the ropes, share their knowledge, and help you avoid those rookie mistakes.
How do you find a good mentor?
Networking. Go to industry events, join online groups. Talk to people.
Put yourself out there.
Exactly. Don't be shy. Ask questions. Show that you're eager to learn.
The injection molding world seems pretty welcoming.
It is. There are so many people who are passionate about this stuff, and they're always happy to help.
You mentioned earlier that not purging the machine properly is a common mistake.
It is. It's easy to forget about, but it's so important.
Can you walk us through how you purge a machine?
Sure. First, you gotta make sure the machine is hot enough to melt any leftover plastic from the last run.
Okay.
Then you use a purging compound. It's like a special cleaning agent for molding machines. You inject that through the machine and it pushes out all the old plastic.
And how do you know when it's done?
You watch the purging compound as it comes out of the nozzle.
Okay.
You're looking for a nice, even color and texture. That means it's clean.
So you're basically inspecting it visually.
Exactly. Once it looks good, you can switch to the new plastic and start molding.
Okay. You also talked about cooling time being important.
It is.
Any tips for figuring out how long to cool apart.
It depends on the material, the thickness of the part, and a few other things. Okay, but generally, thicker parts need more cooling time than thin parts.
Makes sense. How do you measure the cooling time, though?
It's not just about how long the part sits in the mold.
What else is there?
You also need to think about the cooling rate, how fast the temperature goes down.
So it's about how efficiently it cools, not just how long it cools.
Exactly. And there are tools that can help you figure out the best cooling time and cooling rate for your specific part.
Like what?
Well, one of the coolest is a thermal imaging camera.
What's that?
It basically shows you the temperature of the part as it cools.
Oh, wow.
You can see if there are any hot spots or areas that are cooling too slowly.
So you can adjust the cooling system or even change the mold design if you need to.
Exactly. It's a really powerful tool.
We've talked a lot about monitoring and controlling all these different things in injection molding.
We have.
But what about that human element, you know, intuition and experience?
That's what separates the good molders from the great molders.
So it's not just about the technology. It's about the person running the machine.
It is. You can have all the fancy equipment in the world, but if you don't know how to use it properly, you're not going to get good results.
So how do you develop that intuition experience.
That's the best teacher. The more you work with injection molding machines, the more you'll understand how they work and how to get the best out of them.
It's like anything. The more you practice, the better you get.
Exactly. And it's also about being observant. Pay attention to what's happening during the molding process. Listen to the sounds, watch the plastic flow, feel the temperature of the mold.
So use all your senses.
Exactly. The more you observe, the more you'll learn and the better you'll be able to troubleshoot problems when they come come up.
Speaking of problems, one of the articles mentioned short shots.
Oh, yeah, short shots. Everyone hates those.
What are they?
It's when the plastic doesn't completely fill.
The mold, so you end up with a partial part.
Exactly.
What causes that?
Lots of things. But one of the most common is not enough injection pressure. If the pressure's too low, the plastic can't overcome the resistance of the mold and it doesn't fill completely.
Like trying to blow up a balloon with a wee breath.
Exactly. You need enough force. What else Sometimes there's a blockage in the flow path.
Like a clogged nozzle or something?
Exactly. Or a problem with the runners inside the mold.
So it's like a kink and a hose?
Exactly. The plastic can't get through.
Okay, so what do you do if you start seeing short shots during a production run?
First, you gotta investigate. Look at the part itself. See if there are any clues about what's causing the problem.
Like what?
Well, is the short shot happening on every part or just some of them? Is it always in the same spot or does it move around? Those clues can help you narrow down the possibilities.
So you're playing detective again.
Exactly.
It's the next step.
Check the injection pressure. Make sure it's set correctly for the material in the mold.
Okay.
If that's not the problem, then check for blockages in the flow path, the.
Nozzle, the runners, all that.
Exactly.
What if you find a blockage? How do you get rid of it?
Sometimes you can clear it with a tool or by increasing the pressure for a bit. But sometimes you have to take the mold apart or even replace some parts. It can be. But that's part of the challenge and the fun of injection molding.
We talked about feel before. How do you develop that intuition?
It takes time and practice, but it's worth it. Once you have that feel, you can really start to master the process.
So what's the secret?
Pay attention. Observe everything that's happening during the molding cycle. Listen to the sounds. Watch the plastic flow. Feel the temperature of the mold.
Use all your senses.
Exactly. The more you observe, the more you'll understand and the better you'll be able to anticipate problems and solve them.
So it's about being present in the moment?
It is. It's about being fully engaged in the process.
We've talked about a lot of technical things, but what about the business side of injection molding?
Oh, yeah, that's important too.
One of the articles talked about using simulation software to save money.
Absolutely. Simulation software is a powerful tool for businesses. It can help you optimize the molding process, reduce costs and increase profits.
How so?
Well, for one thing, you can use it to reduce prototyping costs. Instead of building expensive physical prototypes, you can test different designs virtually.
So you can try out different ideas without spending a lot of money.
Exactly. And you can also use simulation software to optimize material usage.
How so?
The software can predict how much material you'll need for each part. So you can minimize waste and reduce your material costs.
Especially important These days, with prices going up all the time.
Absolutely. And it's good for the environment too. Less waste means less pollution.
Any other ways simulation software can save money?
Oh, yeah. You can use it to reduce energy consumption.
Okay.
By optimizing the molding process, you can reduce cycle times and use less energy.
So you're saving money on your energy bills.
Exactly. And you can also reduce labor costs. By automating certain tasks, you can free up your operators to focus on more important things.
Makes sense.
Simulation software is becoming essential for any injection molding business that wants to stay competitive.
Okay, so we've talked about the present. What of the future of injection molding? What's coming next?
Oh, there are so many exciting things happening right now. One of the biggest is 3D printing.
3D printing for injection molding?
Yeah. You can use 3D printing to make.
The molds themselves instead of machining them out of metal.
Exactly. It opens up a whole new world of possibilities for mold design.
Like what?
You can create really complex shapes and intricate details that would be impossible or really expensive to make with traditional methods. And 3D printed molds can be made much faster than traditional molds.
So you can get your products to market faster.
Exactly. Speed is everything these days.
Are there any downsides to 3D printed molds?
Well, they're not as durable as metal molds yet.
Okay.
So they might not be good for high volume production, but the technology is improving rapidly.
That's cool. So 3D printing could really change the game for injection molding.
It could, and it's just one example of the exciting things happening in the field. Another area I'm excited about is artificial intelligence.
AI for injection molding?
Yeah, it sounds futuristic, but it's already happening. People are developing AI algorithms that can analyze data from the molding process and use that data to optimize settings, predict problems, and even control the machine in real time.
Wow. So it's like having a super smart computer running the show.
Exactly. It's like having a virtual expert on hand 24 7.
That's amazing. We've covered a lot of ground today.
We have. It's been a great discussion.
I feel like I've learned so much.
Me too. It's always good to talk about injection molding.
Before we wrap up, I want to go back to that idea of injection molding as both a science and an art.
Ah, yes, the perfect balance.
You mentioned mentorship being important for developing that intuition.
Absolutely. Finding a good mentor can make all the difference.
Any advice for finding a mentor network?
Go to events Join online communities, talk to people. Don't be afraid to ask for help.
That's great advice. The injection molding community seems really supportive.
It is. We're all passionate about what we do, and we want to see each other succeed.
I love that sense of community.
Me too. It's one of the best things about this industry.
Well, on that note, I think it's time to wrap up this deep dive into injection molding that's good to our listener. I hope you've learned a lot about injection pressure and holding pressure and how.
To use them to make amazing plastic parts.
Exactly. Remember, it's all about continuous learning and improvement. Don't be afraid to experiment and push the boundaries.
And if you ever get stuck, reach out to the community. There's always someone willing to help.
So keep learning, keep experimenting, and keep molding.
Happy molding, everyone. You can create really complex shapes and intricate details that would be impossible or really expensive to make with traditional methods.
Wow.
And 3D printed molds can be made much faster than traditional molds.
So you can get your products to market faster.
Exactly. Speed is everything these days.
Are there any downsides to 3D printed molds?
Well, they're not as durable as metal molds yet. Okay, so they might not be good for high volume production, but the technology is improving rapidly.
That's cool. So 3D printing could really change the game for injection molding.
It could, and it's just one example of the exciting things happening in the field. Another area I'm excited about is artificial intelligence.
AI for injection molding.
Yeah, it sounds futuristic, but it's already happening.
Really?
People are developing AI algorithms that can analyze data from the molding process and use that that data to optimize settings, predict problems, and even control the machine in real time.
Wow. So it's like having a super smart computer running the show.
Exactly. It's like having a virtual expert on hand 24 7.
That's amazing. We've covered a lot of ground today.
We have. It's been a great discussion.
I feel like I've learned so much.
Me too. It's always good to talk about injection molding.
Before we wrap up, I want to go back to that idea of injection molding as both a science and an art. Ah, yes, the perfect balance.
You mentioned mentorship being important for developing that intuition.
Absolutely. Finding a good mentor can make all the difference.
Any advice for finding a mentor network?
Go to events, join online communities, talk to people. Don't be afraid to ask for help. That's great advice. The injection molding community seems really supportive.
It is. We're all passionate about what we do, and we want to see each other succeed.
I love that sense of community.
Me, too. It's one of the best things about this industry.
Well, on that note, I think it's time to wrap up this deep dive into injection molding. Sounds good to our listener. I hope you've learned a lot about injection pressure and holding pressure and how.
To use them to make amazing plastic parts.
Exactly. Remember, it's all about continuous learning and improvement. Don't be afraid to experiment and push the boundaries.
And if you ever get stuck, reach out to the community. There's always someone willing to help.
So keep learning, keep experimenting, keep molding.
Happy molding, everyone.
And that's a wrap for this deep dive. Thanks for