Podcast – What Causes Injection Molded Polypropylene Parts to Collapse?

Collapsing injection molded polypropylene part in a manufacturing setting
What Causes Injection Molded Polypropylene Parts to Collapse?
Nov 06 - MoldAll - Explore expert tutorials, case studies, and guides on mold design and injection molding. Learn hands-on skills to enhance your craft at MoldAll.

All right, let's go ahead and jump into another deep dive. And I've got to say, this one's particularly interesting. Oh, yeah, it's all about injection molding.
Okay.
But specifically, you know, those polypropylene parts, like all that everyday plastic stuff?
Yeah.
Well, we're going to be looking into why they sometimes just collapse.
Interesting.
So the listeners has provided a bunch of excerpts, you know, from this article called what causes Injection Molded Polypropylene Parts to Collapse?
Title.
And we're going to kind of like, you know, distill all that down to the important stuff and just have a little chat about it.
Sounds fun.
So, like, right off the bat, the article is pointing to this thing called material shrinkage as a major culprit.
Right.
I mean, I know, you know, things shrink like, my sweater's in the dryer.
Yeah.
But with polypropylene, it's like, even a little bit of change can be disastrous. Yeah.
It's not just the overall shrinkage, see, it's the unevenness of it. Like the article mentions, you know, Polypropylene shrinks between 1.5 to 3%, you know, depending on the type.
Okay.
So picture this, right? Building a skyscraper. Okay. But every floor shrinks a little differently.
Oh, wow.
It wouldn't take much for the whole thing to just, like, go totally off kilter.
That's a terrifying image.
Yeah.
So are you saying that thicker sections shrink more than thinner ones?
That's exactly it.
And is that what causes, like, the collapse?
It's a big part of it, yeah. Okay. It creates all the stress within the part, you know, makes it really vulnerable.
So, like, how do manufacturers even begin to, you know, combat this?
Well, for starters, they got to pick the right type of polypropylene.
Okay.
Some are way more prone to shrinkage than others.
Ah, so it's not just the material itself.
No.
It's also, like the mold. Super crucial.
Yeah. The mold is key, okay. And you got to design that mold so it's minimizes those uneven thicknesses as much as possible.
So it's, like, way more complex than those LEGO molds I had as a kid.
Oh, way more complex, huh? Yeah. You gotta imagine, like, designing something that makes sure everything cools and solidifies evenly, but then at the same time, you have to account for how that molten plastic is gonna flow and shrink, you know, all while it's taking shape.
Okay. So it's a lot.
It is. It's a whole process.
Yeah.
And they even use features like ribs, filets, you know, like little support beams. To kind of distribute the stress.
Okay. My brain is starting to hurt a little bit.
Yeah. It's a lot to take in, but.
Let'S try and move on to the next thing.
Okay. What's next?
Injection pressure.
Right.
I feel like I should get this, you know, from squeezing a tube of toothpaste.
Yeah.
But it sounds like there's a bit more to it.
Well, yeah, toothpaste is a decent starting point.
Okay.
I mean, you need enough pressure to get all the toothpaste out, right? Yeah. It's the same with injecting molten polypropylene into the mold.
Okay.
If you don't have enough pressure, the mold won't fill up all the way.
And then.
And then you're left with weak spots.
Ah, okay.
And that's just asking for collapse, you know?
But how do they figure out, like, how much pressure is enough?
Right.
It can't be the same for every single thing.
Oh, no, not at all.
Okay.
It really depends on the design of the part, the type of polypropylene. Okay. And even, like, the mold itself, you know? Okay. How many entry points it has, how the air can escape.
Wait, escape?
Yeah.
You mean, like, molds need ventilation?
Absolutely. It's like a pressure cooker.
Oh, okay.
If there's no way for the steam to escape, it's going to explode.
Okay, I get it.
And it's kind of similar with the mold. You see, if those gases get trapped, they build up pressure.
Okay.
And then the mold doesn't fill properly.
Makes sense.
And that can cause a bunch of problems, including collapse. Right.
So it sounds like there's way more to these molds than I ever thought.
There's a lot going on under the surface. Yeah.
This is, like, a whole intricate dance.
It is.
Between the material, the pressure, and now, like, ventilation, it's all connected. I'm starting to feel overwhelmed, honestly.
A lot. I know.
All right, how about we cool down for a minute?
Yeah, good idea.
But not too much. This deep dive is getting really, really interesting.
Yeah. It's just getting started.
Okay, let's keep going.
All right, what's next?
Okay, so we've talked about shrinkage and pressure, and my brain is, like, doing mental gymnastics over here.
A lot to take in. Yeah.
But before we move on.
Okay.
I kind of want to go back to shrinkage for a sec.
Sure.
You mentioned it can be as tiny as, like, 2%.
Yeah.
But, like, how much of a difference does that really make in the real world? I mean.
Oh, it makes a huge difference.
Really?
Yeah. Think about it like, this okay. Imagine you're making a thousand tiny gears a watch.
Right.
If each gear shrinks even a little bit differently. Yeah. They won't mesh. Right. The whole watch is basically useless.
Wow. So even a tiny difference can have massive consequences. No wonder everyone's so worried about this shrinkage thing.
It's a big deal.
But you said uneven wall thickness is the real troublemaker, Right?
Exactly.
That lopsided cake analogy.
Yeah, exactly.
So in real life, what would that look like?
Well, imagine like molding a container with thin walls.
Yeah.
But a thick base. That base is going to shrink more. Right. And it's going to pull on those walls. Could warp the whole thing.
Oh, wow.
Could even crack it.
So what if you, like, have to have different wall thicknesses? Could you just use higher pressure?
Ah, see, that's where it gets tricky.
Okay.
You can't just force more plastic into the thin areas.
Oh, really?
Nope. Higher pressure can actually make things worse.
How?
It can cause something called flashing.
Flashing?
Yeah. Basically, the molten polypropylene gets squeezed out of the mold.
Oh, I see.
Creates excess material defects, all sorts of problems.
So it's all about balance.
Exactly.
Like finding that sweet spot.
You got it.
And I remember the article mentioned something about ribs and fillets.
Oh, yeah, those are important.
Can you remind me what those are again?
Yeah. So those are design features, and they act like little reinforcements.
Okay.
Imagine a bridge with support beams.
Yeah.
That's kind of what ribs do inside a plastic part.
Makes sense.
They help distribute the stress from shrinkage.
Okay.
So it doesn't all concentrate in one spot. And the filets, those are smooth transitions between different thicknesses.
Yeah.
Basically, they prevent those sharp corners, which can also be weak points.
You see, it's incredible how much thought goes into all this. Yeah. It's a whole science just to prevent a little piece of plastic from collapsing.
It's more than just a little piece of plastic when it's part of something bigger, you know?
That's true. That's true.
Yeah.
Okay, let's shift gears a bit and talk about mold design.
All right. Mold design.
I'm starting to see why it's so crucial.
It's the foundation of the whole process. Really?
In what way?
Well, it's not just a container. It's like a precisely engineered tool that dictates how the plastic is going to flow, how it's going to cool, how it's going to take shape.
So we talked about the even wall thickness.
Right.
What other factors are there?
Oh, there are a bunch.
Like what?
The placement of the gate for example, the gate. Yeah. That's where the molten plastic enters the mold.
Ah, okay.
And it has to be positioned just right.
Why?
So the plastic flows smoothly and evenly into every part of the mold.
So it's like designing a system of pipes.
Exactly.
To distribute water efficiently, but with molten plastic.
That's a great analogy.
And then there are those vents we talked about.
Oh, yeah. Those are super important for letting the.
Air and gases escape.
Exactly.
So if those gases can't escape, what happens?
Pressure builds up.
Okay.
Mold doesn't fill properly, and then you.
Have lots of problems.
Exactly.
Okay. This mold design stuff is a whole other world.
It's pretty complex. Yeah.
We've still got one more factor to go, though, Right. Cooling time.
Right.
You said it's about finding that sweet spot. Not too hot, not too cold.
Exactly.
But how do they even figure that out?
Well, they have to consider a few things, like the thickness of the part.
Okay.
The type of polypropylene, the mold temperature.
That's a lot of variables.
It is.
Sounds like a nightmare to calculate.
Well, luckily, they have some pretty cool tools to help them out these days.
Like what?
They use simulation software.
Simulation software?
Yeah.
So they basically run virtual experiments.
That's exactly it.
Before making the actual part.
Yep.
Wow.
They can change different variables in the simulation.
Like what kind of variables?
Mold temperature.
Okay.
Flow rate of the cooling fluid. See how it affects the part.
It's like a crystal ball for cooling.
You got it.
That's incredible.
It's pretty amazing technology.
This is more than just a game, though, right?
Oh, yeah, definitely.
This cooling thing is super important for preventing collapse.
Absolutely crucial.
Like, you know how when you're making candy, you got to cool it just right.
Exactly.
Or it cracks or stays gooey.
Right.
And with polypropylene.
Yeah.
That gooey part could be a disaster waiting to happen.
You don't want that.
So this whole process, it's way more intricate than I ever imagined.
There's a lot going on behind the scenes.
And it's not just about preventing collapse, is it? It's also about efficiency.
Right.
Like doing it in the most efficient way possible.
Exactly. They're always trying to optimize everything.
Okay, my mind is officially blown.
It's pretty amazing, isn't it?
This little plastic part.
Well, they're not always so little.
That's true. But, you know, it's a whole world of engineering marvels.
It really is.
But let's bring it back down to earth for a sec.
Okay.
Have you ever seen, like, a real world example of this? Of what of a polypropylene part? Like, totally failing?
Oh, yeah, definitely.
Like something that shows how important it is to get all this stuff right.
Oh, absolutely.
Tell me about it.
Okay, so I remember this one case.
Yeah.
This company was making these big storage containers.
Okay.
And suddenly they started collapsing left and right.
Really?
Yeah, it was a mess.
What happened?
Well, they were using the same polypropylene, same mold design. They've been using it for years. No problems.
What was the issue?
Turns out they switched suppliers for their cooling fluid and the new fluid wasn't as efficient.
Ah, I see.
It was a subtle change.
Yeah.
But it threw the whole cooling process off balance.
Wow. So even a small change can have.
A big impact abdominal effect.
So have you seen any, like, really cool solutions for preventing collapse?
Oh, there's some clever ones out there.
Give me an example. Okay.
So this company was making collapsible water bottles. Thin walls, you know, and to prevent them from collapsing.
Yeah.
They put these intricate ribs inside. Yeah. Like spiraling ribs. Added strength, but also looked really cool.
So they turned a potential weakness into a design feature.
Exactly.
That's awesome.
It's a great example of how engineering and design can work together.
It really shows how much creativity there is in the world of plastics.
Yeah. It's not all just boring stuff.
Speaking of creativity.
Yeah.
I have a challenge for our listener.
Ooh, a challenge. I like it.
All right, listener, here's the challenge.
Okay. I'm listening.
Imagine you're designing a brand new polypropylene part.
Right.
Maybe it's like a container or part for some new gadget. Whatever.
Got it.
Knowing everything we've talked about.
Yeah.
Shrinkage, pressure, mold design, cooling stuff, what's the one thing you would prioritize to prevent that part from collapsing?
That's a tough one.
It is, right?
Yeah. There's so much to think about.
There is.
And like we said, there's no one right answer.
Nope.
It all depends on the part.
Yeah. It's purpose. But I'm really curious to hear what our listener comes up with.
Me too. Should be interesting.
Yeah. Maybe they'll come up with the next big innovation.
You never know.
In, like, collapse proof polypropylene.
That'd be cool.
It would. Okay. But before we get too carried away.
Yeah.
I feel like we need to talk about something else.
What's that?
The future of polypropylene.
Oh, yeah, good point.
We've been so focused on, like, preventing these collapses, we haven't even looked ahead.
What's coming next?
Exactly?
Well, there's a lot Happening, actually.
Like what?
For one, recycled polypropylene is becoming a big deal.
Ah.
So taking all those plastic bottles and containers, giving them a new life.
Like a second chance.
Exactly.
That's amazing for, like, sustainability.
Huge for sustainability.
Reducing waste, all that.
Absolutely. Well, they're also looking into bio based polypropylene.
Bio based?
Yeah. Made from plants.
Whoa.
So imagine like plastic parts.
Yeah.
But made from renewable resources instead of fossil fuels. Exactly.
Wow. That would be a game changer.
That would be huge.
So it seems like the future of polypropylene is all about, like, pushing boundaries.
Yeah. It's about finding new solutions and innovation. Absolutely.
And what about 3D printing?
Oh, yeah. 3D printing is opening up a whole new world for polypropylene.
How so?
Well, imagine being able to print custom parts on demand.
Yeah.
With super complex shapes and details.
That would be incredible.
Yeah. Things you could never do with traditional molding.
So it's like taking all those challenges.
We talked about shrinkage, pressure, cooling, and finding totally new ways to deal with them.
That's amazing.
It is pretty cool.
This deep dive has been a real eye opener for me.
I'm glad you enjoyed it.
I started out thinking about, like, plastic parts collapsing.
Right.
And now I'm picturing a future where polypropylene is leading the way in sustainability and innovation. Exactly.
It's amazing what you can learn when you dig a little deeper.
It really is. So I hope our listeners feel in the same way.
I hope so too.
We've covered a lot today.
We have.
From the basics of shrinkage to the potential of bio based polytropy.
Yeah. It's been a good one.
And hopefully we've inspired our listener to.
Think a little differently about plastic.
Yeah. And to appreciate the science behind it all.
Definitely.
So on that note.
Yeah.
We're going to wrap up this deep dive.
Okay.
Into the world of collapsing polypropylene parts.
A world full of surprises.
It really is. And remember that challenge we gave you, the design challenge? Yes. We want to hear your ideas.
Definitely.
Share them with us on social media.
Let's keep the conversation going.
And until next time. Yeah. Keep exploring, keep questioning, and keep diving deep. Thanks for