Podcast – How Does the Thickness and Width of a Film Gate Relate to Each Other?

Diagram of an injection molding machine's film gate area
How Does the Thickness and Width of a Film Gate Relate to Each Other?
Nov 26 - MoldAll - Explore expert tutorials, case studies, and guides on mold design and injection molding. Learn hands-on skills to enhance your craft at MoldAll.

Welcome back, everyone. Today we're gonna be doing a deep dive into something that's pretty essential to injection molding, and that is something called the film gate.
Yeah.
And, you know, for our listeners out there, you know, this is something that you might not think too much about, but it really does have a big impact on.
Yeah, it's pretty crucial.
Yeah. On the quality of your parts. On the. You know, the whole process, really.
Definitely.
So we've got some.
We've got a lot.
Yeah. What kind of sources do we have for this?
We've got some technical papers. We've got some case studies. We've even got a few analogies.
Oh, great. I love a good analogy.
Always good to have.
So, yeah, let's. Let's jump right into it.
Okay.
So, you know, when we talk about the film gate, we're really talking about, you know, the entry point for the molten plastic as it goes into the mold.
Yeah. Basically, it's that. It's that channel that the molten plastic flows through to get into the mold cavity.
And, you know, the size of that channel can really.
It matters a lot.
Yeah. Does it matter just, like, the overall size, or are we talking.
Well, we're really talking about the thickness and the width of the gate, because those two dimensions really dictate how that plastic flows into the mold.
So it's like a valve.
Exactly. It's like a valve controlling that flow. And, you know, you can think of it like. Like trying to drink a milkshake through a really thin straw.
Okay.
Versus a wide one.
Right.
You know, the wider straw is going to let that milkshake through a lot faster.
Okay.
And it's the same principle here. A wider film gate allows more molten plastic to flow through, which means faster filling of that mold cavity.
So if we're trying to, you know, increase the speed of our production, that's something that we should definitely be looking at.
Absolutely. One of the sources we looked at, they actually saw a significant increase in filling speed just by increasing the gate width from 50 millimeters to 100.
Wow. Just like that.
Yeah. And they kept the thickness the same. It was just that width change that made the difference.
Okay. So wider is faster, generally.
Yeah, but. There's always a but. Right.
There's always a but with injection molding.
Exactly. Because, you know, honey isn't exactly the same as molten plastic. Right.
True, true.
There are other factors to consider.
Yeah. Like the viscosity of the material itself.
Exactly. And the injection pressure. All of that comes into play.
So it's not just about making the gate as wide as possible. Possible.
No, it's not as simple as that.
There's got to be some downsides to that.
Yeah, there are definitely some potential issues if you go too big with that gate.
Like, what could happen?
Well, you know, going back to that honey analogy.
Okay.
If that opening is too wide, you risk overflowing and making a mess. Right, right, right. And it's the same with the film gate. If it's excessively wide or thick.
Yeah.
You might run into problems like melt.
Spraying and meld spraying is.
Melt spraying is essentially where the plastic bursts out of the gate.
Oh, so it's not.
It's not controlled anymore?
It's not a clean move?
No, it's a mess. You get defects, you waste material. It's not good.
And it's probably bad for the mold, too, Right?
Yeah, potentially. You know, if you've got too much pressure and too large of a gate.
Yeah.
You could damage the mold.
Right. So it really is a balancing act, then.
It is, it is.
You know, we want to make sure it's fast, but we also want to make sure we don't have these negative consequences.
Precisely. You need to find that sweet spot.
Okay. So that's kind of, you know, that's one aspect of it. The speed.
Yeah.
But I'm also curious about how all of this affects the actual, like, quality of the final product.
Yeah, that's a great point.
You know, we don't just want something that's made quickly. We want something that's also high quality.
Right, right.
So how do those film gate dimensions play into that?
Well, they actually have a direct impact on the uniformity and stability of your part.
Okay.
So think about a rectangular piece, for example. If your gate isn't sized correctly or positioned correctly, the molten plastic might not spread out evenly as it fills that mold.
Okay.
And that can lead to inconsistencies in the wall thickness and, you know, sometimes even warping.
Yeah. I was reading about a case study where they were able to reduce warping in a rectangular piece just by adjusting the gate size.
Yeah. It's amazing how such a small detail can have such a big impact.
Yeah, it's pretty impressive.
Yeah. And, you know, it's not just about the structural integrity either.
Right.
There's also the visual aspect to consider.
Right.
You know, proper gate sizing can minimize those gate marks.
Oh, gate marks.
Yeah, you know, those little blemishes where the plastic entered the mold.
Right.
And it can also help reduce weld lines.
And weld lines are.
Weld lines. Are those Kind of unsightly seams that you sometimes see on plastic parts where the plastic didn't quite fuse together properly during the filling process.
So if we're, you know, if we're trying to make a product that looks really sleek and high quality. Yeah, we gotta pay attention to this.
It makes a huge difference.
Yeah. It's not just about, you know, how quickly we can make it.
It's the whole package.
It's gotta look good too.
Exactly.
So, okay, so we've talked about, you know, the size, we've talked about how it affects quality.
Right.
But I'm also thinking about the material itself.
Yeah, that's a crucial factor because, you.
Know, not all plastics are created.
No, definitely not.
So does that play a role in how we choose our film gate dimensions as well?
Oh, absolutely.
Okay.
Because different materials have different flow characteristics and they behave differently during the injection molding process.
So there's no one size fits all solution when it comes to.
Unfortunately not. No.
To film gates.
No. You've got to consider the material.
Okay.
For sure.
So, like, give me an example.
Okay. So let's take polypropylene, for example.
Okay.
Polypropylene, which is often used for things like food containers.
Right.
Now, polypropylene is a very fluid material. It flows easily. So a thin, wide gate works well in that case because you want to let that material flow in quickly and smoothly and prevent any kind of pressure buildup.
Right.
But on the other hand, let's say you're working with something like a glass fiber reinforced plastic.
Okay.
That's a much more viscous material.
Much thicker.
Yeah, it's thicker. It's not going to flow as easily. So in that case, you actually need a thicker gate to maintain that pressure and make sure the material doesn't solidify before it fills the mold.
Right. So it's like choosing the right tool for the job.
Exactly.
You wouldn't use a hammer to screw in a light bulb.
You wouldn't.
And in the same way you wouldn't use the same film gate dimensions for every single type of plastic.
Absolutely.
You've got to tailor it.
You've got to consider the material to.
What you're working with.
For sure.
Okay. So we've talked about the size, we've talked about the material.
Right.
I'm guessing there are other design considerations as well.
Oh, definitely.
When it comes to the shape of the gate.
Yeah. The shape and location of the bait are both really important.
So it's not just a simple, you know, rectangular opening.
Not always.
There's more to it than that.
Yeah. You've got fan gates, you've got ring gates. There are all sorts of different designs.
And I'm guessing those have their own pros and cons.
They do, they do.
Depending on.
It really depends on the geometry of the part you're making and the flow characteristics you're trying to achieve.
Right. So even something as simple as, like, where you place that gate on the mold.
Yeah. The gate location is crucial.
Can make a difference.
It can drastically impact how that plastic fills the cavity and ultimately how the final product turns out.
So it sounds like there are a lot of variables, a lot to think about to consider here.
Yeah.
So where do you even begin with trying to optimize all of this?
That's a great question. And that's actually what we're going to be diving into next time.
Okay. So we've laid the groundwork here.
We have.
We've talked about, you know, all these.
Different factors, all the things to consider.
And now we're going to start talking about how to actually put this knowledge into practice.
That's right.
So stay tuned, everybody. We'll be back with part two of our deep dive into the film gate.
See you then.
Very soon.
Coming up.
All right.
Looking forward to it.
Me too. All right. Yeah. So where do we even begin with trying to optimize all of this?
Well, it can seem a bit overwhelming. Right. When you start thinking about all these variables.
Right.
But I think the key is to not get too bogged down in the technical details at first.
Okay.
You know, start by thinking about it conceptually. One of the sources I came across, they compared optimizing film gate dimensions to finding the perfect rhythm in a song.
Okay.
Like a musician, you know, they're not just blindly following a formula.
Right.
They're listening.
They're feeling it.
Yeah, they're feeling it. They're adjusting, and they're finding that sweet spot that makes the music sound just right.
So it's like an art as much as it is a science.
Exactly. And that's why I think hands on experimentation is so crucial.
Yeah. You got to get in there, you got to tinker. Tinker with it. Yeah.
Try things out, observe what happens, and then fine tune your approach based on those observations.
So it's like you're constantly gathering data.
Yeah, yeah.
And then using that data to improve your process.
Exactly. Like a scientific experiment where you're constantly refining your hypothesis.
Right.
Based on the evidence you're gathering.
So it's not like you just, you know, set it and forget it. No, no, you're constantly tweaking things.
It's an ongoing process.
Okay. So we've got that kind of experimental mindset.
Right.
Are there other things that we can do to kind of, you know, point ourselves in the right direction?
Absolutely.
Okay.
There are definitely some strategies that we can use, you know, in addition to just that trial and error.
Okay.
Our sources point to several factors.
Okay.
That can influence our film gate optimization. And it goes beyond just the width and thickness.
Okay.
Like we talked about earlier.
Right.
The shape of the gate, for example.
Oh, yeah, you mentioned fan gates and ring gates. Exactly.
And those are. Those are different from just a simple.
Yeah. They're not just your standard rectangular opening.
Rectangular opening.
They have a specific shape for a reason.
Okay, so how do those come into play, then?
Well, they each have their own advantages, depending on what you're trying to achieve. So, for example, a fan gate.
Okay.
That spreads the molten plastic out over a wider area, which can be really useful for filling large, flat surfaces.
I see.
You know, to make sure the material flows evenly.
So if you've got like a big, you know, panel, something like that.
Yeah. Fan gate might be a good choice.
Okay.
A ring gate, on the other hand, that's often used for cylindrical parts.
Okay.
Because it allows the plastic to flow in a circular pattern.
Right.
Which gives you a more balanced fill.
So it's not just, you know, picking a random shape.
No, no, no.
There's a reason.
There's a strategy behind it.
Choosing one over the other, for sure. Okay. So that's the shape.
Right.
We've also got the location. Yeah. Gate location is super important.
Okay.
Think of it like a. Like positioning a sprinkler in your yard. You know, you want to make sure that sprinkler is positioned so it covers the whole lawn. Exactly. You want that water to reach every corner of your lawn.
Right.
And it's the same with the gate location. You want to make sure that molten plastic is going to flow to every corner of the mold of the mold cavity.
So a well placed gate can make sure that we get a nice, even fill.
Exactly. It can help prevent things like short shots.
Short shots.
Yeah. Where the plastic doesn't quite reach.
Doesn't fill the whole mold.
Yeah. It doesn't fill the entire cavity.
Okay.
And it can also help with things like reducing sink marks.
Sink marks? Are those.
Yeah, Those little depressions.
Yeah.
On the surface of the part. That can happen if the plastic doesn't cool evenly.
Yeah. So we're really trying to avoid all of these potential problems.
We're Aiming for a smooth, high quality part every time.
So, you know, it seems like there's a lot of kind of finesse involved here.
Yeah, yeah.
It's not just, you know, plug in the numbers.
It's not just a simple formula and.
Get your perfect results.
No, there's a bit of art to it. But thankfully we do have some pretty incredible tools at our disposal these days.
Oh, yeah, you mentioned earlier, like simulation software.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah. These simulation programs.
So what do those do?
They're incredibly powerful. They allow engineers to basically simulate the entire injection molding process on a computer.
Wow.
So you can see how the plastic is going to flow through the mold. You can experiment with different gate designs, different parameters.
So before we even make the mold.
Exactly.
We can test things out.
Yeah. You can troubleshoot potential problems virtually before you even create a physical prototype.
That sounds like a huge time saver.
It is.
And probably a money saver too.
Yeah, yeah, definitely. Because you're not, you know, wasting material on.
Exactly. You can iterate and optimize in a digital environment.
So these simulations are really revolutionize the industry. Revolutionize the industry. Wow.
Yeah, it's pretty amazing.
So are those. Are those, like, readily available? Are they expensive?
There are a variety of different software packages available. Some are more sophisticated than others.
Right.
Some are more expensive than others. But there are definitely options out there.
So if our listener is interested in kind of exploring that further.
Yeah. I encourage them to do some research.
Okay.
And see what's available.
But, you know, even with those simulations.
Yeah.
Even with all the fancy software, even.
With all the technology, there's still something.
To be said for that. Hands on experience.
Absolutely.
Right.
You know, getting your hands dirty.
Yeah.
Actually running the machines, observing the results firsthand.
Because, you know, sometimes those simulations might not.
They don't always capture everything. Capture everything. Yeah.
There are always real world nuances that you can only learn through experience.
Right. It's one thing to see it on a screen.
Right.
It's another to actually be there.
To feel it.
To feel it, to see it, to hear it. To hear it. Yeah, yeah.
To experience it with all your senses.
So it sounds like we've got a lot of options here.
You do.
You know, we've got the simulations, we've got the hands on experimentation.
Right.
But I imagine our listener might be wondering, you know, where can I learn more about all of this?
Yeah, that's a great question.
Like, are there resources available? Are there places I can go?
Absolutely.
Okay.
There's a wealth of information out there. You know, while we can't mention specific sources.
Right.
I would definitely encourage our listener to explore books, articles, online forums dedicated to injection molding.
Okay.
There are some really fantastic resources out there.
So there's a whole community.
Yeah, a whole community.
People who are into this.
Absolutely.
So, you know, if you get stuck, you're not alone.
You're not alone.
Reach out, ask questions. There are people who are happy to help.
Okay. That's good to know.
Yeah. And remember, practice makes perfect.
It always does.
Yeah. Don't be afraid to experiment. Make mistakes, learn from them. Right. That's how you truly master any craft.
So, you know, we've talked about a lot here. We've covered, you know, the science behind the melt flow.
Right.
The impact of those gate dimensions on quality.
Right.
And, you know, even some of those advanced optimization strategies.
We've gone pretty deep.
We've gone pretty deep. Yeah.
Yeah.
So before we wrap up this part, I'd love to get, you know, one final thought from you.
Okay.
Just something for our listener to kind of chew on.
Sure.
You know, as they continue their own exploration of this topic.
Okay. So, you know, we've been focusing a lot on how to optimize that film gate.
Right.
To create a better individual product.
Right. To make a good part.
Yeah. But what if we zoom out a little bit and think about the bigger picture?
Okay.
What if we apply these same principles.
Of optimizing the film cage.
Yeah. Of flow balance optimization to the entire production process.
Oh, so not just the individual part.
No, the whole system.
Okay.
You know, thinking about things like material selection, mold design, cycle times, energy consumption.
So you're talking about a more holistic approach.
Exactly.
You know, taking a step back and seeing how all of these pieces fit together.
Yeah. Seeing the interconnectedness of it all and finding ways to make the entire system more efficient. More efficient. More sustainable. More in harmony.
That's a really interesting way to think about it.
Yeah. And I think that's where the real power of this knowledge lies. It's not just about making better widgets. It's about creating a more responsible and innovative manufacturing ecosystem for the future.
So it's like we're taking those principles that we've learned.
Yeah.
And applying them on a grander scale to make a real impact.
Yeah. And I think that's something that's worth striving for.
Yeah. Definitely. Food for thought for our listener out there.
Absolutely.
All right, so we'll be back very soon with part three.
Sounds good.
Of our deep dive into the film gate.
See them.
All. Right. It really is. You know, Thinking about the film gate in that context, in that bigger picture, it's. It's pretty eye opening.
It is. It highlights how important it is to understand the fundamentals. When you really grasp those core principles, you start to see the connections, and that's where the innovation comes in.
So for our listener out there, you know, they're working on their own injection molding projects.
Right.
What would you say is the one key takeaway? Hmm.
That's a tough one.
You know, what's that? One thing that they should really keep in mind.
Yeah.
As they're tackling these challenges?
Well, if I had to boil it down to one thing, I'd say don't underestimate the power of observation and experimentation. It's so easy to get caught up in the technical stuff.
Right.
The simulation data, the specs, the search.
For that perfect formula.
Right. And sometimes.
Yeah.
The most valuable insights come from just paying attention to what's happening right in front of you.
It's like being a detective looking for clues.
Exactly.
You know, noticing those patterns, those subtle things. Yeah.
Those little details that can lead to a breakthrough.
So don't be afraid to experiment, to try different things.
Exactly.
To push the boundaries a little bit, See what happens. Yeah. Embrace those aha moments.
Yeah.
You know, those unexpected results, sometimes those.
Are the best ones.
Yeah.
That leads you down a new path.
That's what makes this field so exciting.
It is.
You know, there's always something new to.
Learn, always a new challenge.
Right.
It keeps you on your toes.
All right, well, as we wrap up this deep dive into the world of film gates and injection molding, I'd love to leave our listener with one final thought.
Okay.
You know, just a little something to ponder as they continue their exploration of this topic.
So we've used a lot of analogies today. We have the milkshake, the race car, the musician finding that perfect rhythm.
It's been fun.
It has.
Yeah.
So what if we take that a step further and think of the entire manufacturing process as a symphony?
A symphony.
Yeah.
Okay.
With all these different instruments all working together to create a harmonious whole.
I like that.
Right.
It's a beautiful image.
So how can you, as the conductor, as the engineer, the designer, the maker.
Yeah.
How can you use your understanding of these principles to not only create better products.
Right.
But to create a more efficient, a more sustainable, a more beautiful and infinity of manufacturing?
That's the challenge.
That's a great challenge. You know, it's a reminder that even in this world of, you know, plastics and molds, right. There's still room for artistry.
There is.
And for innovation.
So keep exploring.
Yeah.
Keep experimenting.
Keep pushing the boundaries, and keep listening.
For those harmonies that might just lead you to that next breakthrough.
Well said.
All right, well, thanks for joining us on this deep dive.
It's been a pleasure.
Until next time, keep those gears turning and those ideas